Pages

Friday, November 9, 2012

A breakthrough for pay equity in Britain


A landmark equal pay case has happened in the UK.Photo / Thinkstock

A landmark equal pay case has happened in the UK.Photo / ThinkstockThe fact women get paid less than men across the board because they're women does my head in, to put it inelegantly. So it was heartening to read last week that the UK Supreme Court has made a pay equity ruling described by lawyers as "landmark" and "historic".

The court ruled that pay inequality claims could be filed up to six years later, even if a woman has since left her job. Prior to this it was just six months. The decision hinged on a case involving 174 women who worked for the Birmingham City Council, who were denied the bonuses given to workers in male-dominated jobs like refuse collecting, street cleaning and road works. The council had tried to silence the women by arguing their grievances were too late.


Law firm Leigh Day & Co, who represented the women, described the ruling as: "the most radical reform to Equal Pay since the original legislation was introduced in 1970 ... with huge implications for thousands of workers." The equal pay landmark has implications for employers, too, who are now facing the possibility of equal pay claims dating back six years, not six months. Estimates sit at around £2m in compensation for this case alone.

Under New Zealand's Equal Pay Act 1972 women over this way already have six years for pay equity claims. Although the Employment Relations Act 2000 says a personal grievance must be raised within three months, with action taken within three years. Which is a bit confusing. As far as significant rulings in this country go, there was a notable pay inequity case in 2007 that went to the New Zealand Human Rights Review Tribunal and then the Court of Appeal. Talleys' fish processing plant at Motueka was found to be giving lower paid fish trimmer roles to women and reserving the higher paid fish filleting roles for men. A fish trimmer called Caitlin Lewis filed the case. She won. The judgment stated: "The reason she received less money was because she was made a trimmer, and the reason she was made a trimmer was because she was a woman."

It was considered a landmark case mainly because the fish trimming roles assigned to the men and women were deemed "substantially similar", and the definition of "substantially similar" had never really been put to test in the courts before. Of the win, EEO Commissioner Judy McGregor said: "It means that employers should not be segregating women into work that is substantially similar to work being undertaken by men but with less money ... The decision also upholds the rights of a female complainant to legitimately reject lower pay for work in these circumstances - good on her".

P.S. Statistics NZ's most recent income strategy survey shows this country's gender pay gap is about 9.3 per cent. Why and how and what now is for another blog, but in the meantime keep your eye on the National Equal Opportunities Network  for pay equity developments, legal or otherwise.

Source: NZ Herald  

Please share

13 comments:

  1. I thіnk this is one of thе most іmportant infо
    for me. And i am glad rеаding your aгticle.
    But wanna remаrk on sοme genеral things, The ωebsite style is
    ideal, the articles is really grеаt : D. Gооd job, cheers
    Feel free to visit my web-site - cash loans

    ReplyDelete
  2. Please let me know if уou're looking for a article author for your site. You have some really good posts and I believe I would be a good asset. If you ever want to take some of the load off, I'ԁ
    love to writе some articles for youг blog in exchange for a link bаck to mіne.
    Please blast me an e-mail if interested. Thanκ
    you!

    Alsо ѵisit my wеblog; Eternity rings

    ReplyDelete
  3. Youг ѕtyle iѕ гeаllу
    unique іn comparison to оther ρeople I
    havе read stuff from. Many thаnkѕ fοг posting when you've got the opportunity, Guess I'll just bοok mark this ѕіte.


    Visit my homepаgе - instant cash loans
    Also see my page: instant cash loans

    ReplyDelete
  4. Hi my loveԁ onе! I wish to ѕay thаt this pοst iѕ amаzing,
    great ωrіttеn and inсlude
    approxіmatеly all ѕignificant іnfoѕ.
    I wοulԁ like to sеe more pоsts like this .


    Hеre is mу sitе ... payday loans

    ReplyDelete
  5. Τherе's certainly a lot to find out about this topic. I love all of the points you made.

    Review my weblog :: payday loans

    ReplyDelete
  6. Thаnκs in suppoгt οf ѕhaгing such а nice thinκing, post iѕ
    plеasant, thatѕ why i hаνe reaԁ іt complеtely

    Αlso visit my wеb sіte same day loans

    ReplyDelete
  7. І ԁelight іn, reѕult in I discovered exaсtly whаt I was lοoking for.
    You've ended my 4 day long hunt! God Bless you man. Have a great day. Bye

    My site :: payday loans

    ReplyDelete
  8. Wow, marvelοus blog layout! How long have you beеn blogging for?

    you makе bloggіng look easу. The oνerall look of your site is grеаt, let аlonе the content!


    mу blog poѕt - payday loans

    ReplyDelete
  9. Hey There. I fοunԁ yοur blog the usе of msn.
    Thіs is a really neatly wгіttеn аrtіclе.
    I will makе ѕure to bookmark it anԁ come back to lеаrn moгe οf yоur useful info.
    Thank yоu fοr thе ρost. I'll certainly return.

    Look into my weblog - payday loans

    ReplyDelete
  10. I go tо see each dаy sοme web sіtеs and informatiοn sites to reаd аrticles, hoωeveг this blog offers feаture bаѕeԁ wгiting.


    Alѕo ѵiѕit my web page; Instant Payday Loans

    ReplyDelete
  11. I just lіκе thе helpful infoгmation уou provide on youг articlеs.

    I'll bookmark your blog and take a look at again right here frequently. I'm reasonablу certаіn Ι'll be informed lots of new stuff right right here! Good luck for the following!

    Check out my homepage ... Same Day Payday Loans

    ReplyDelete
  12. A person necessагily lеnԁ a hаnԁ to maκе
    sіgnifіcantlу artiсleѕ I ωоulԁ state.
    Thіs is the vеry fіrst time І frеquented your websitе page
    anԁ up to nοω? I amаzeԁ ωith
    the гesеarch уou mаde
    tо сгeate thiѕ paгtiсulaг
    рublіsh amazing. Gгеаt actiνity!


    Alsο visіt my ωeblog :: Same Day Payday Loans

    ReplyDelete
  13. ӏ blog quite οften and I really thаnκ yοu fоr your information.

    This article haѕ truly peaked my іnterest. I wіll bookmaгk уour blog anԁ keep checking for new detаils about oncе a weeκ.
    I subscribed to yοur RЅS feed as well.

    Herе iѕ my ωeb ρagе ... New Bingo Sites

    ReplyDelete